H&SS News
Carnegie Mellon Study: Emotions Continue to Influence
Americans' Reaction to 9/11 and the Risk of Terrorism
The passage of time can distort how people remember their feelings after the attacks
PITTSBURGH-The release of the transcripts of New York City emergency communications from the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks brought back the flood of emotions that Americans experienced during the worst attack in the nation's history. As a recent Carnegie Mellon University study demonstrates, intense emotions have a powerful effect on how Americans continue to perceive the risk of terrorism and their memories of 9/11. The study was published in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied.
The researchers surveyed a national sample of Americans late in 2001, and then again a year later. Each time, they created experiences that accentuated one of the multiple emotions that the attacks evoked: fear, anger or sadness. One year out, the respondents' emotional reactions to the attacks continued to predict their perception of the risk of terrorism: Those who had their fear heightened were more pessimistic about the likelihood of future attacks and coping with the risk of terrorism, while those who had their anger heightened were more optimistic.
Overall, the respondents in 2002 believed future attacks were less likely than they had the previous year. However, when asked to recall their predictions from 2001, people remembered being more optimistic than they actually had been. That is, they remembered having seen a safer world than they actually had shortly after the attacks - a clear demonstration of hindsight bias. Reliving emotions colored their view of the past. Those who were made angrier remembered being more optimistic, whereas those made more fearful remembered being more pessimistic. Reliving emotions did not, however, reduce hindsight bias.
“The study raises two cautions for citizens thinking about terror or other hot topics. One is that they need to monitor their emotions. If they allow themselves to be angered, they may exaggerate the probability of success in anti-terror programs,” said Baruch Fischhoff, the lead author and the Howard Heinz University Professor of Social and Decision Sciences and Engineering and Public Policy at Carnegie Mellon.
"The second caution is that they need to look for historical records when judging the wisdom of past decisions, rather than relying on their own memories," Fischhoff said.
The research also was conducted by Roxana Gonzalez and Jennifer Lerner, both in Carnegie Mellon’s Department of Social and Decision Sciences, and Deborah Small, now at the Wharton School of Business at the University of Pennsylvania. The study was supported by the National Science Foundation, the National Institute of Mental Health and the American Psychological Association (Division 9).
About the Quick Links
|
|
 |
| |
H&SS is on Facebook
Stay connected to H&SS and fellow students, alumni, faculty and staff on Facebook. Become a fan now! |
| |
Research Shows People Blame
External Agents When Bad Things Happen to Them
New research by Carey K. Morewedge reveals people attribute external agents - other people or supernatural forces - when something goes wrong, but not when things happen the way they wanted or expected. Read more... |
| |
Carnegie Mellon To Celebrate Grand Opening Of
Behavioral Decision Research Lab in Downtown Pittsburgh
The Social and Decision Sciences Department and its Center for Behavioral Decision Research is opening a behavioral decision research lab in downtown Pittsburgh. At the Carnegie Mellon Research Café, located on the second level of Fifth Avenue Place, downtown workers and visitors will be able to earn money or gift cards for participating in studies on decision making such as consumer spending and saving, health behaviors like dieting and smoking, and what causes happiness. Read more... |
| |
Kiron K. Skinner Reappointed
To Chief of Naval Operations Executive Panel
Kiron K. Skinner, an associate professor of social and decision sciences and director of the International Relations and Politics Program, has been reappointed to the Chief of Naval Operations Executive Panel by U.S. Defense Secretary Robert Gates. Read more... |
| |
SDS Professor Paul Fischbeck Links Health Care Debate To Risk of Dying in the U.S. and Europe
The current health care debate in the United States is complicated. Trade-offs between heath care expenditures, lifestyle choices and life expectancy have been suggested but seldom clearly demonstrated. Paul Fischbeck, professor of social and decision sciences and engineering and public policy. uses risk of dying data in the U.S. and Europe to illustrate differences in health care systems. Read more... |
| |
Humanities Center Lecture Series: "Is Water the New Oil? The New Water Monopolies and the World's Poor"
Monday, Nov. 9 at 4:30 pm: Karen Piper, an English professor at the University of Missouri-Columbia, will discuss how the World Bank supports policies that force poor countries to privatize their water supplies and the consequences of water privatization. Read more... |
| |
Happily Hopeless: Professor George Loewenstein Discovers Optimism Can Be Detrimental to Mental Health
New research by Social and Decision Sciences Professor George Loewenstein and Dylan M. Smith, Aleksandra Jankovic and Peter A. Ubel of the University of Michigan shows that holding on to hope may not make patients happier as they deal with chronic illness or disease. The study tracked and surveyed patients with both reversible and irreversible colostomies over a six-month period to measure their emotional well-being. The results confirm that people do not adapt well to situations if they're believed to be short-term. Read more... |
| |
Information Systems Program Receives Andrew W. Mellon Foundation Grant
The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation has granted the Information Systems (IS) program $206,000 over the next two years to continue its "Information Systems in the Community" summer program. The program brings students from Historically Black Colleges and Universities to Carnegie Mellon for an intensive, six-week session in which they learn software development best practices, project management and teamwork. The program, derived from the highly successful IS major within H&SS, started six years ago with an initial grant from the Mellon Foundation. Read more... |
| |
Modern Languages Hosts Lecture on the Challenges in the Performance Assessment of Speaking at Advanced Levels
Wednesday, Nov. 4: The Modern Languages Department will host a lecture by Timothy McNamara, professor of allied linguistics from the University of Melbourne at 3:30 p.m. in Margaret Morrison A14. Read more... |
| |
CMU Press Publishes New Edition of Chuck Kinder's Famed Honeymooners
Kinder's chronicle of two writers pursuing fame and freedom in the Bay Area during the 1970s now includes an introduction by author and screenplay writer Jay McInerney and two previously unprinted sections: The Lost Chapters and The Lost Love Letters. Read more... |
| |
Carnegie Mellon Appoints New Co-Director
Of Center for the Neural Basis of Cognition
Michael J. Tarr, a new professor of psychology, will co-direct the Center for the Neural Basis of Cognition (CNBC). The CNBC is a joint project between Carnegie Mellon and the University of Pittsburgh devoted to investigating neural mechanisms and their impact on human cognitive abilities. Read more... |
| |
Distracted Driving Podcast
Listen to Marcel Just, the director of Carnegie Mellon's Center for Cognitive Brain Imaging, discuss his research that shows why cell phones distract drivers. Listen here. [Requires iTunes.] |
| |
Facing the Economic Turning Point: A New G-20 Agenda Critical for Restoring Growth and Confidence
On Sept. 23, the university community gathered to tackle issues that world leaders would be focusing on at the G-20. Under the leadership of Professor Kiron Skinner, the day-long conference - co-hosted by Carnegie Mellon and the Atlantic Council - explored the economic and social forces at work in the post-economic crisis world. They were joined by U.S. Ambassador to Ireland Daniel Rooney, as well as leaders at the World Bank, PNC Financial Services and BNY Mellon, among others. Read article. Read related report. |
| |
Video: Pittsburgh G-20 Summit Forum
Carnegie Mellon recently hosted a panel of experts discussing the G-20 summit. Topics included discussion on what the G-20 is and what impact it will have. The speakers also discussed the global economy and what challenges it has encountered recently. Members of the panel included H&SS professors Lee Branstetter and Jendayi Frazer.
Watch the video. |
| |
CMU Press Publishes Book on Pittsburgh in the 21st Century
Carnegie Mellon University Press' latest publication is The Paris of Appalachia: Pittsburgh in the Twenty-first Century, a book by Brian O'Neill that gives a hopeful and heartfelt account of why Pittsburgh was able to hold steady during the recent financial crisis. Read more... |
| |
H&SS Summer 2009 Newsletter Available
In this issue: When dreaming is believing; 2009 Cognition Symposium and Guggenheim Fellowships; Study could help with weight loss; David Danks faculty profile; 2009 Harry S. Truman Scholarship winner; and much more. Read more...
|
| |
2009-10 Humanities Center Lecture Series Focuses on Global Connections, Global Responsibilities
Sponsored by Carnegie Mellon's Humanities Center and the Center for the Advancement of Applied Ethics and Political Philosophy, the lectures will focus on the diversity between affluent and economically challenged countries and their influence on one another. For complete dates, topics and speakers, click here.
|
| |
Psychology's Marcel Just Uses Brain Imaging To Show Why Cell Phones Distract Drivers
According to Carnegie Mellon neuroscientist Marcel Just, simply listening to someone speak on the other end of a cell phone is enough to impair driving. Read more... |
| |
H&SS is on Twitter
Stay up-to-date with everything going on in the College of Humanities and Social Sciences on Twitter. Visit twitter.com/CMU_HSS. |
| |
H&SS Researchers Develop Novel Tool To Rank Death Rates
Have you ever wondered what the odds are that you may die in the next year? Would it be from illness or an accident? Is it something you can control? Or is it completely out of your hands? A new Web site, www.DeathRiskRankings.com, developed by researchers and students at Carnegie Mellon University, allows users to query publicly available data from the United States and Europe, and compare mortality risks by gender, age, cause of death and geographic region. Paul Fischbeck, a professor of social and decision sciences and engineering and public policy led the development team. Read more... |
| |
Information Systems Program in Qatar Welcomes Class of 2013
Carnegie Mellon University in Qatar celebrated its Sixth Annual Convocation on Sunday, Aug. 23 and officially welcomed the Class of 2013 to the Carnegie Mellon Qatar family. 92 students make up the new freshman class, making it the largest incoming class at Carnegie Mellon Qatar. 20 students are enrolled in Information Systems. Read more... |
| |
History Department Announces Center for Africanamerican Urban Studies and the Economy 2009-10 Speaker Series
The Center for Africanamerican Urban Studies and the Economy (CAUSE) will launch its 2009-10 speaker series with an opening reception at 4:30 p.m., Friday, Sept. 11, in the Danforth Lounge of the University Center. CAUSE aims to link the historian's interest in race, work and economic change over time with contemporary analyses of politics, the urban labor force and employment policies. Each year CAUSE sponsors a speaker series that features distinguished historians lecturing on African American history in the region and nation. Read more... |
| |
Professor Stephen E. Fienberg
Receives American Statistical Association Award
Stephen E. Fienberg, the Maurice Falk University Professor of Statistics and Social Science, has been named a recipient of the American Statistical Association's (ASA) 2009 Founders Award. ASA is the nation's largest professional statistical society and has a membership base that spans government, industry and academia. Read more... |
| |
Two Social and Decision Sciences Professors Named to Security Panel Convened by National Academies
Baruch Fischhoff and Kiron Skinner have been appointed to the National Academies Committee on Behavioral and Social-Science Research to Improve Intelligence Analysis for National Security. Fischhoff, the Howard Heinz Professor of Social and Decision Sciences, will chair the panel. Read more... |
| |
Two H&SS Professors Win 2009 Guggenheim Fellowships
Mariana Achugar and Terrance Hayes have been confirmed as 2009 Guggenheim Fellows. Achugar is an associate professor of Spanish and second language acquisition skills in the Modern Languages Department, and Hayes is a Creative Writing professor. Read more... |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
